Africa: Twitter Still Failing Women Over Online Violence and Abuse - New Analysis

Amnesty International has evaluated Twitter on progress to guard ladies on platform

The web-based media organization still not doing what’s needed to secure ladies notwithstanding alerts over two years ago

‘Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey needs to coordinate words with activity’ – Michael Kleinman

Twitter is still not doing what’s needed to shield ladies from online brutality and maltreatment in spite of rehashed vows to do as such, new investigation by Amnesty International uncovers, over a long time since the web-based media organization was set clear suggestions for improvement.

Amnesty has delivered a Twitter Scorecard* which reviews the web-based media organization’s record on actualizing a progression of suggestions to handle maltreatment against ladies on the stage since Amnesty originally featured the size of the issue in its 2018 Toxic Twitter report, which uncovered how Twitter is neglecting to keep ladies safe.

Despite some advancement, the organization has completely actualized only one of ten solid proposals, with restricted advancement in expanding straightforwardness on how it handles reports of abuse.

The persevering maltreatment ladies face on the stage sabotages their entitlement to communicate similarly, openly and unafraid. This maltreatment is profoundly intersectional and ladies from ethnic or strict minorities, underestimated ranks, lesbian, promiscuous or transsexual ladies – just as non-double people – and ladies with inabilities are excessively affected by maltreatment on the platform.

Indian creator and dissident, Meena Kandasamy, said:

“Being a Tamil, blended rank lady, who takes a stand in opposition to India’s biased position framework, has demonstrated a dangerous blend on Twitter. I get a downpour of supremacist and sexist maltreatment, including assault threats.

“Twitter consistently is by all accounts playing catchup and is too delayed to even consider addressing the various sorts of misuse ladies face.

“Twitter is a powerful place to express ourselves, but Twitter needs to do more to clean up the platform and make it a safe place for women.”

Rasha Abdul Rahim, Co-Director of Amnesty Tech, said:

“Our examination shows that notwithstanding some advancement, Twitter isn’t doing what’s needed to ensure ladies clients, driving numerous ladies to quietness or blue pencil themselves on the platform.

“We have illustrated clear, direct advances that Twitter can take to make its foundation a more secure spot for ladies to communicate their views.

“Twitter can and must do more to protect women from abuse.”

Twitter neglecting to secure women

Amnesty’s past examination of the stage has uncovered stunning discoveries, including:

a review of lady legislators and columnists in the UK and USA found that an injurious or hazardous tweet was sent to a lady each 30 seconds during 2017;

Analysis in the approach the 2017 UK general political race uncovered that Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic ladies MPs got practically half (41%) of misuse tweets, in spite of there being just about eight fold the number of white MPs in the study;

The same investigation demonstrated that Diane Abbott MP alone got very nearly a third (31.6%) of all injurious tweets analysed.

Since the arrival of Toxic Twitter in 2018, Amnesty International has kept on featuring the size of misuse ladies face on Twitter, remembering for Argentina, India, UK and USA. Then, ladies have kept on standing in opposition to the maltreatment they experience on Twitter, and the organization’s inability to sufficiently respond.

Twitter Scorecard findings

In 2018, Amnesty furnished Twitter with solid proposals on how it can all the more likely meet its common liberties duties, featuring ten that the basic freedoms association accepts are critical to assisting with handling on the web maltreatment against ladies. The Twitter Scorecard utilizes a traffic signal framework to review Twitter’s advancement in executing the suggestions, which spread straightforwardness, revealing components, and upgraded protection and security features.

Due to the absence of important information Twitter gives, it is hard to check the full degree of the issue of online maltreatment. Twitter actually doesn’t give point by point nation level breakdowns of client reports of misuse, nor does it give information about the number of clients report explicit sorts of damaging language, for instance misuse dependent on sex or race.

Twitter is additionally hesitant about revealing itemized data about the quantity of substance arbitrators it utilizes, including what sort of inclusion they give across various nations and languages.

The web-based media stage should be more straightforward regarding how it plans and actualizes computerized cycles to recognize online maltreatment against ladies. While Twitter has uncovered subtleties on how it is utilizing calculations to battle falsehood during the current COVID-19 pandemic, it is yet to give similar degree of straightforwardness on how calculations are utilized to address oppressive tweets.

Twitter has gained ground in certain zones, including improving the requests cycle, by offering more direction to clients on how the cycle functions and how choices are made. The organization was evaluated golden for its endeavors towards expanding clients’ attention to protection and security highlights and in instructing clients on the mischief such maltreatment causes.

 Sign up for nothing AllAfrica Newsletters 

<p class="cta-text">Get the most recent in African news conveyed directly to your inbox</p> 


Nearly wrapped up... 

We have to affirm your email address.

To finish the cycle, kindly adhere to the guidelines in the email we simply sent you.


There was an issue handling your accommodation. If you don't mind attempt again later. 

Michael Kleinman, Director of Amnesty International’s Silicon Valley Initiative, said:

“It is absolutely in Twitter’s capacity to actualize these progressions that would have a genuine effect to a great many ladies’ understanding on the platform.

“Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey needs to match words with action to show he is genuinely committed to making Twitter a safer place for women. We will continue to press the company until we see more changes that truly show that abuse against women is not welcome on the platform.”

Twitter’s response

In reaction to Amnesty’s examination, Twitter recognized it needs to accomplish more. In any case, the organization said its blend of human control and utilization of innovation permits it to take a more proactive reaction to online maltreatment. On distributing disaggregated information by nation or area, Twitter contended this could be available to confusion and give a deceptive impression of the problem.

While Amnesty recognizes that setting is significant, there isn’t anything to stop Twitter giving setting close by information, and the organization’s basic freedoms duties implies it has an obligation to be straightforward by they way it manages reports of savagery and abuse.